Vantage vs Tickmill
Vantage scores 4.8 and Tickmill 4.7, on the same five marks.
We may be paid if you open an account from either link. It never changes a score. 74 to 89% of retail CFD accounts lose money.
At a glance
Spreads are the lowest each broker publishes, not the ones you will usually get. Trustpilot scores are read from Trustpilot and do not feed our score.
Our verdict
Vantage scores 4.8 out of 5 and is fourth of 13 brokers we review. Tickmill scores 4.7 and is sixth. Vantage gets the higher mark for entry cost (4.5 against 4.0) and instruments (5.0 against 4.5). They are level on regulation, spreads and platforms.
Vantage is licensed by two top-tier regulators: ASIC and FCA. It also holds three other licences. Tickmill is licensed by two top-tier regulators: FCA and CySEC. It also holds two other licences.
Both publish spreads from 0.0 pips. Vantage asks for a $50 minimum deposit and Tickmill for $100.
Your protection depends on which company holds your account, and that depends on where you live. It is named in your client agreement, so read it before you deposit.
Mark by mark
The same five marks for every broker, by the same rules. How we score
Costs and limits
Accounts
Vantage
| Account | Minimum deposit | Spreads from | Commission |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard STP | $50 | 1.0 pips | None |
| Raw ECN | $50 | 0.0 pips | $3.00 a lot each side |
Tickmill
| Account | Minimum deposit | Spreads from | Commission |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classic | $100 | 1.6 pips | None |
| Raw | $100 | 0.0 pips | $3 a lot each side |
| TradingView Raw | $100 | 0.0 pips | $3.50 a lot each side |
“From” is the lowest spread a broker publishes for that account, not the one you will usually get.
Licences
Vantage
| Regulator | Company and licence number | Our rating |
|---|---|---|
| ASICAustralian Securities and Investments Commission, Australia | Vantage Global Prime Pty Ltd, AFSL 428901Read on an older page of its own site | Top-tier |
| FCAFinancial Conduct Authority, United Kingdom | Vantage Global Prime LLPUK residents, through vantagemarkets.co.uk | Top-tier |
| VFSCVanuatu Financial Services Commission, Vanuatu | Vantage Global Limited, 700271The company behind vantagemarkets.com | Other |
| FSCAFinancial Sector Conduct Authority, South Africa | Vantage Markets (Pty) Ltd, 51268 | Other |
| CIMACayman Islands Monetary Authority, Cayman Islands | Vantage International Group Limited, 1383491 | Other |
Tickmill
| Regulator | Company and licence number | Our rating |
|---|---|---|
| FCAFinancial Conduct Authority, United Kingdom | Tickmill UK Ltd, 717270 | Top-tier |
| CySECCyprus Securities and Exchange Commission, Cyprus | Tickmill Europe Ltd, 278/15 | Top-tier |
| FSAFinancial Services Authority, Seychelles | Tickmill Ltd, SD008The company behind tickmill.com | Other |
| FSCAFinancial Sector Conduct Authority, South Africa | Tickmill South Africa (Pty) Ltd, FSP 49464 | Other |
A top-tier licence protects you only if the company that holds it is the one your account is opened with.
Platforms
Who each suits
Vantage is a good fit if you
- Trade often and want spreads that start at 0.0 pips
- Chart on TradingView and want to trade from it
- Want a wide choice of markets
- Need a swap-free account
Tickmill is a good fit if you
- Trade often and want spreads that start at 0.0 pips
- Chart on TradingView and want to trade from it
- Need a swap-free account
Vantage: strengths and cautions
- Two top-tier licences: ASIC and FCA
- Spreads from 0.0 pips
- Four platforms, including MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5
- More than 1,000 CFDs
- Vantage says it charges no deposit fee
- vantagemarkets.com opens accounts with its Vanuatu company, not its UK or Australian one
- Not open to residents of the United States, Canada, India, China, Hong Kong or Singapore
Tickmill: strengths and cautions
- Two top-tier licences: FCA and CySEC
- Spreads from 0.0 pips
- Four platforms, including MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5
- Tickmill says it charges no withdrawal fee
- tickmill.com is run by its Seychelles company
- A $100 minimum deposit
- More than 600 instruments, fewer than most brokers here
Questions
Is Vantage or Tickmill better?
Vantage scores 4.8 out of 5 and is fourth of 13 brokers we review. Tickmill scores 4.7 and is sixth. Vantage gets the higher mark for entry cost (4.5 against 4.0) and instruments (5.0 against 4.5). They are level on regulation, spreads and platforms. A higher score does not make a broker right for you. Check which of its companies would hold your account, because that decides the protection you get.
Which is better regulated, Vantage or Tickmill?
Vantage is licensed by two top-tier regulators: ASIC and FCA. It also holds three other licences. Tickmill is licensed by two top-tier regulators: FCA and CySEC. It also holds two other licences. For regulation we mark Vantage 4.7 out of 5 and Tickmill 4.7.
Which has lower spreads, Vantage or Tickmill?
Both publish spreads from 0.0 pips. That is the lowest spread each one publishes, not the spread you will usually get, and the lowest one is often on an account that also charges commission.
Which has the lower minimum deposit, Vantage or Tickmill?
Vantage asks for a $50 minimum deposit and Tickmill for $100. The figure can change with the account type and the payment method, so check it on the broker’s own deposit page.
Which platforms do Vantage and Tickmill offer?
Vantage has MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView and Vantage App. Tickmill has MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView and Tickmill App.
More comparisons
See both next to the other 11 brokers
The full ranking shows every broker on the same five marks, highest score first.

